Classic CakesCharacter and Themed Party CakesTaylor Swift Number CakesSmash CakesSheet CakesSport CakesCupcakes & Cake PopsBaptism and Communion CakeBaby Shower & Gender RevealCandles & More

All Cakes

Please place orders 48 business hours in advance for pick up and NYC delivery. Orders for Saturday and Sunday are accepted through Thursday.  Orders are ready for pick up at 11am. Deliveries are usually made between 9am - 5pm. 

Need a cake for today? We have 6” cakes available daily on first come basis at our UES shops.

Filter Right
FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old

Filter

Sort by
Down
Left Right
White with Black Ribbons: Graduation Cake
From $ 115.00
Left Right
Celebration Cake
From $ 65.00
Round vintage ornate cake
Left Right
Vintage Ornate Cake
From $ 82.00
A round edible flower cake
Left Right
Flower Cake
From $ 82.00
Golf themed cake
Left Right
Golf Sport Cake
From $ 94.00
Basketball Sport Cake
From $ 74.00
Soccer Cake
Soccer Sport Cake
From $ 74.00
Baseball Cake
Left Right
Baseball Sport Cake
From $ 74.00
A pink cake with pink piping and white ribbon.
Left Right
Little Bow Cake
From $ 74.00
A tini bit older green heart shaped cake. The cake has green ornate piping a fondant olive with a stick and fondant letters that say a tini bit older.
Left Right
A Tini Bit Older Martini Cake
From $ 148.00
heart shaped vintage ornate cake
Left Right
Vintage Style Ornate Heart Cake
From $ 105.00
Left Right
Classic Cake
From $ 60.00
yellow and purple ombre cake
Left Right
Ombre Cake
From $ 60.00
A rainbow cake
Left Right
Over the Rainbow Cake
From $ 72.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Cake with rosettes on top
Left Right
Rainbow Sprinkle Cake
From $ 52.00
Colorful Sprinkle Explosion Cake
Left Right
Sprinkle Explosion Cake
From $ 72.00
Vintage heart shaped ornate cake with pearls and disco balls
Left Right
Vintage Style Ornate Heart Cake with Pearls and Disco Balls
From $ 105.00
A pink tini bit older heart shaped cake. The cake has pink ornate piping a fondant olive with a stick and fondant letters that say a tini bit older.
Left Right
A Tini Bit Older Pink Martini Cake
From $ 148.00
Brown Heart Shaped Ornate Tini Bit Older Espresso Cake.
Left Right
A Tini Bit Older Espresso Martini Cake
From $ 148.00
Two Round ornate astrology cakes. One teal and green and one pink and orange.
Left Right
Astrology Sign Vintage Ornate Cake
From $ 127.00
White and black ornate cake with black ribbons
Left Right
White with Black Ribbons: TTPD Taylor Swift Cake
From $ 105.00
A yellow cake decorated with mini hot dogs
Left Right
Hot Dog Cake
From $ 72.00
Ornate tie dye cake with butterflies
Left Right
The Taylor Swift Tie Dye Swiftie Cake
From $ 105.00
royal blue and white cake with cold sprinkles
Left Right
The Royal Blue Cake
From $ 72.00
emerald green cake with gold details
Left Right
The Emerald Cake
From $ 82.00
Green cake with carrots
Left Right
Bunny Patch Cake
From $ 65.00
A pink cake with little red hearts
Left Right
Hearts Cake
From $ 70.00
Blue and pink swatch gender reveal cake
Left Right
Gender Reveal Cake
From $ 84.00
Safari Cake decorated with a Monkey and Lion.
Left Right
Wild One Safari Cake
From $ 155.00
A pink cake decorated with little cherries
Left Right
Cherry Cake
From $ 72.00
A white cake with little colorful hearts
Left Right
Colorful Hearts Cake
From $ 85.00
Round cake with tiny hearts
Left Right
Hearts Cake White and Red
From $ 70.00
A blue cake decorated with clouds
Left Right
Cloud Cake
From $ 64.00
Green round ornate cake
Left Right
Brat Cake
From $ 70.00
Black snake cake
Left Right
The Black Snake Cake
From $ 127.00
Watermelon Cake
Left Right
Watermelon Theme Cake
From $ 60.00
A moana cake with figurines
Moana Cake
From $ 105.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Sheet can with rosettes on top
Rainbow Sprinkle Celebration Sheet Cake
From $ 82.00
A classic chocolate cake with rosettes
Left Right
Classic Rosette Cake
From $ 52.00
Rainbow sprinkle number cake
Left Right
Sprinkles Number Cake
$ 104.00
Blue and Purple and Yellow and Pink Candy Drip cakes
Left Right
Candy Drip Cake
From $ 105.00
a purple cake with candy rainbows
Left Right
The Rainbows Cake
From $ 72.00
Brazilian Chocolate Brigadeiro cake
Left Right
Brigadeiro Cake, Traditional Chocolate
From $ 72.00
A unicorn cake
Left Right
Unicorn Cake
From $ 115.00
A two tiered rainbow unicorn cake
Left Right
Unicorn Rainbow Tiered Cake
$ 300.00
hot pink round ornate cake
Left Right
Ornate Hot Pink Cake
From $ 82.00
A white cake decorated with little yellow taxi cabs.
Left Right
I Love NYC Taxi Cake
From $ 92.00
Two paw patrol cakes - one pink and one blue.
Left Right
Paw Patrol Cake
From $ 105.00