Classic CakesCharacter and Themed Party CakesTaylor Swift Number CakesSmash CakesSheet CakesSport CakesCupcakes & Cake PopsBaptism and Communion CakeBaby Shower & Gender RevealCandles & More

All Cakes

Please place orders 48 business hours in advance for pick up and NYC delivery(Custom Orders require 7+ days). Orders for Saturday and Sunday are accepted through Thursday.  Orders are ready for pick up at 11am on weekdays and 8am on weekends. Deliveries are usually made between 9am - 5pm. 

Need a cake for today? We have 6” cakes available daily on first come basis at our UES shops.

Filter Right
FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old

Filter

Sort by
Down
Left Right
Pizza Cake
From $ 105.00
Left Right
Ribbon Cake
From $ 72.00
Left Right
US Open Tennis Ball Cake
From $ 74.00
Left Right
Celebration Cake
From $ 65.00
Round vintage ornate cake
Left Right
Vintage Ornate Cake
From $ 82.00
Left Right
Custom Color Number Cake
$ 105.00
A tini bit older green heart shaped cake. The cake has green ornate piping a fondant olive with a stick and fondant letters that say a tini bit older.
Left Right
A Tini Bit Older Martini Cake
From $ 148.00
heart shaped vintage ornate cake
Left Right
Vintage Style Ornate Heart Cake
From $ 105.00
A pink cake with pink piping and white ribbon. A top angle
Left Right
Little Bow Cake
From $ 74.00
Left Right
Classic Cake
From $ 60.00
Golf themed cake
Left Right
Golf Sport Cake
From $ 94.00
Basketball Sport Cake
From $ 74.00
Soccer Cake
Soccer Sport Cake
From $ 74.00
Baseball Cake
Left Right
Baseball Sport Cake
From $ 74.00
royal blue and white cake with cold sprinkles
Left Right
The Royal Blue Cake
From $ 72.00
emerald green cake with gold details
Left Right
The Emerald Cake
From $ 82.00
A yellow cake decorated with mini hot dogs
Left Right
Hot Dog Cake
From $ 72.00
Watermelon Cake
Left Right
Watermelon Theme Cake
From $ 60.00
Lemon Theme Cake
From $ 72.00
A pink cake decorated with little cherries
Left Right
Cherry Cake
From $ 72.00
Ice Cream Cake
From $ 72.00
Left Right
Strawberry Cake
From $ 72.00
Left Right
Berry First Birthday
From $ 72.00
yellow and purple ombre cake
Left Right
Ombre Cake
From $ 60.00
A rainbow cake
Left Right
Over the Rainbow Cake
From $ 72.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Cake with rosettes on top
Left Right
Rainbow Sprinkle Cake
From $ 52.00
A pink, orange and red disco ball cake
Left Right
Disco Ball Cake
From $ 105.00
Colorful Sprinkle Explosion Cake
Left Right
Sprinkle Explosion Cake
From $ 72.00
Vintage heart shaped ornate cake with pearls and disco balls
Left Right
Vintage Style Ornate Heart Cake with Pearls and Disco Balls
From $ 105.00
A pink tini bit older heart shaped cake. The cake has pink ornate piping a fondant olive with a stick and fondant letters that say a tini bit older.
Left Right
A Tini Bit Older Pink Martini Cake
From $ 148.00
Brown Heart Shaped Ornate Tini Bit Older Espresso Cake.
Left Right
A Tini Bit Older Espresso Martini Cake
From $ 148.00
Two Round ornate astrology cakes. One teal and green and one pink and orange.
Left Right
Astrology Sign Vintage Ornate Cake
From $ 127.00
White and black ornate cake with black ribbons
Left Right
White with Black Ribbons: TTPD Taylor Swift Cake
From $ 105.00
Ornate tie dye cake with butterflies
Left Right
The Taylor Swift Tie Dye Swiftie Cake
From $ 105.00
A pink cake with little red hearts
Left Right
Hearts Cake
From $ 70.00
A white cake with little colorful hearts
Left Right
Colorful Hearts Cake
From $ 85.00
Round cake with tiny hearts
Left Right
Hearts Cake White and Red
From $ 70.00
Blue and pink swatch gender reveal cake
Left Right
Gender Reveal Cake
From $ 84.00
Left Right
Gender Reveal Little Bow Cake
From $ 84.00
Safari Cake decorated with a Monkey and Lion.
Left Right
Wild One Safari Cake
From $ 155.00
Green cake with carrots
Left Right
Bunny Patch Cake
From $ 65.00
A blue cake decorated with clouds
Left Right
Cloud Cake
From $ 64.00
Green round ornate cake
Left Right
Brat Cake
From $ 70.00
A moana cake with figurines
Moana Cake
From $ 105.00
Rainbow Sprinkle Sheet can with rosettes on top
Rainbow Sprinkle Celebration Sheet Cake
From $ 82.00
A classic chocolate cake with rosettes
Left Right
Classic Rosette Cake
From $ 52.00
Rainbow sprinkle number cake
Left Right
Sprinkles Number Cake
$ 104.00
Blue and Purple and Yellow and Pink Candy Drip cakes
Left Right
Candy Drip Cake
From $ 105.00